InStyle's Digital Beauty Editor went blonde and it completely changed the way she filled in her brows. Find out how she discovered the miracle eyebrow pencil shade that works for everyone. Mac's impeccable brow pencils are the BEST, hands down. They come in these shades: blonde, dirty blonde, taupe, black.

• Mac Dirty Blonde Eyebrow Pencil
• Anastasia Perfect Brow Pencil Blonde
• Best Blonde Brow Pencil
• Eyebrow Pencil Dark Blonde
• Light Blonde Brow Pencil

This Tom Ford was the last brow pencil I wanted to try. I recently made a post with many other blonde brow shades. This Tom Ford is not quite as good as I was hoping. I was hoping for a touch more soft waxy pencil but it’s fairly dry and hard like the others I reviewed previously. The color is lighter for a blonde like I prefer, but because of the hardness of the pencil I’m not 100% behind it. It has a hexagonal shape, and due to the hardness of the pencil lasts a long time on. It’s not as hard as the Cle de Peau, but not as soft and waxy as the MAC or the Hourglass. It’s in between. This has a sharpener built in by the spoolie. You twist it out and can sharpen the edge to get a finer line.

Mac Dirty Blonde Eyebrow Pencil

Anastasia Perfect Brow Pencil Blonde

Honestly for the high prices they all cost I still love the MAC Impeccable Brow Pencil the most. Sadly it’s discontinued which is what started the search for a new brow pencil for me. I love the color of the Cle de Peau but hate the hardness, the Charlotte Tilbury is also too hard and too cool in color, the Hourglass is a great softer texture and overall this would win this competition. However, the color is too dark for a blonde it’s more of a dirty blonde shade. I’ll use them up but the search goes on to replace my discontinued MAC pencil. I do like the color of the Maybelline blonde brow pencil but it’s a touch too hard and pulls my hairs out while I’m applying it. They all do this to some degree, but the Maybelline is worse.

Best Blonde Brow Pencil

Eyebrow Pencil Dark Blonde

Light Blonde Brow Pencil

L to R: Charlotte Tilbury Grace K, Hourglass Blonde, Cle de Peau 203, MAC Impeccable Brow Blonde, Tom Ford Brow Blonde